An exploration of the Golden Age of Comics, through the lens of Hideouts & Hoodlums, the comic book roleplaying game.
Wednesday, January 11, 2023
Amazing Man Comics #11 - pt. 3
Wednesday, April 13, 2022
Thrilling Comics #3 - pt. 2
I'm tempted to stat wild hill warriors as berserkers. I could also make them 2nd level fighters, using the level title of warrior from That Other Game. I could also just use natives, since that's the broad stereotype being used here.
I've never seen elephants in an arena before! Too bad Doc has Raise Elephant prepared. And a Leap power (looks like II or better) that makes escaping from an arena super-easy.And here we've got a line-up of standard cliches - the big cat (a panther, this time) in the cage, the damsel in distress...and somehow Doc gets to the panther before it gets to the damsel? Now, I've covered many times before in this blog that random initiative needs to trump common sense when it comes to who goes first in a comic book story, but, Doc is wrecking things in the same turn that the panther is first attacking. So, we can only assume, then, that the panther missed with every attack on Virginia, even though it didn't even need to roll very high (reminds me of my rolls when I'm playing!).
Sunday, May 30, 2021
Prize Comics #2 - pt. 2
You know, this issue really isn't winning me over, and Jupiter, Master Magician isn't helping. Let's ignore for the moment that Jupiter's antennae look like pencils sticking out of his hair. Let's pretend that monster is drawn less goofy-looking and more like the D&D gargoyle it superficially resembles. Let's even try to ignore the fact that, if the city is shielded by rays so he can't locate it, then how does Jupiter know it's far away? Instead, let's talk about how dumb your supporting cast member has to be to volunteer to be a decoy, while you watch a monster carry him away, even though you have no idea if the monster is going to eat him the minute it leaves town with him. And even if they're convinced from the crystal ball that the monsters are taking their abductees to this far away city, maybe the abductees don't need to show up alive, or with their heads still on.
Monday, March 1, 2021
Famous Funnies #68 - pt. 2
Thursday, February 11, 2021
Master Comics #1 - pt. 1
Master Man builds his castle on the highest peak...where? The highest peak on Earth would be Mount Everest, but the rest of this story sure doesn't look like it takes place in Tibet. The highest peak in the United States is Mount Whitney -- making Master Man the first confirmed Californian superhero.
Master Man's ability to run 100 MPH is the Race the Train power. He also uses Leap II at rivers and, it looks like, Imperviousness when he reaches town. Obviously, he is the superhero class.
It's interesting that he bares his chest. Is his shirt not bulletproof? The power description intentionally doesn't specify if items worn are protected by this power; this is something the player and Editor should work out between themselves and aim to be consistent thereafter.
The bad guys are a mixed group of four gangsters and thugs, probably half of each.So, a "black jungle" is right next to India? Riiight. This page is pretty unbearable, not just for that, but for Sin-Gee falling into a trap and David just leaves her there!
I'm only sharing this page because I want to spend a little time on this death trap. The theory behind it is, by binding one of David's hands, he can't dodge during the knife fight. I wouldn't necessarily call him prone, because he still has some range of movement, so maybe he's +2 to be hit, plus this can kill him because it still qualifies as a deathtrap.
Monday, January 18, 2021
Detective Comics #37 - pt. 2
The plot here is that a bomb blows up a "conference of government officials," with no specifics as to the nature of the conference or the level of the officials present. Forensic evidence points to a suspect, which our hero Bart Regan collects from the scene, which seems odd because you would think a forensic specialist instead of a spy would be collecting evidence.
An assassin tries to shoot Bart in the back, but facing doesn't matter in Hideouts & Hoodlums; if you win the initiative roll, you can turn around and deck someone behind you, just like Bart does.
Undercover, Bart tries to join Ligoni's mob, what we would call a terrorist organization today. Ligoni is a skilled knife thrower and tests his new recruits by throwing knives at them until they flinch. Bart stands still for 16 knives before Ligoni gives up. I would use two mechanics for this: one is rolling to attack Bart with each throw. Since he's trying to miss, a successful "hit" becomes a miss. The other is requiring a save vs. plot from Bart to see if he flinches. If I was really mean, I'd make him make 16 different saves, but the odds would really be against him then. I would have him roll once and, if he missed, the number he rolled is the number of knives he can withstand without flinching. Then, to be fair, I would roll randomly (on a 20-sided die) to see how many knives Ligoni throws.
During the initiation, a mobster walks in who knows Bart and recognizes him immediately. Bart was "disguised" only with a change of clothes to look like a criminal, which is not enough to warrant a mobster having to make a saving throw to see through it.
Whimsically, the newspaper headline saying the bombers were captured is from The Daily Star, the newspaper Superman then worked for. This could be seen as the first cross-title continuity between Action Comics and Detective Comics.
In Cosmo, the Phantom of Disguise, Cosmo's friend is a ship captain tasked with delivering unspecified "chemicals" to England. I immediately thought this was suspicious and did some digging and saw that we did send chemicals to England -- illegal mustard gas -- in 1943. We never do learn if it's that type of chemical being delivered.
It normally took a steamship 15 days to reach England from New York then, but the captain seems to suggest it will take 1 whole month with the circuitous route they planned around the "war-infested areas," which actually does sound like quite a reasonable precaution.
Cosmo, in disguise, hears talk of mutiny on board the ship (after a skill check for listening?). In a clever bit, Cosmo pretends to shoot the captain with a blank cartridge, then dumps a dummy overboard, so the mutineers will trust him and the captain can still move about the ship. Less clear is how Cosmo further distracts the mutineers with an explosion timed to when he drops the dummy in the water. Are the explosives inside the dummy? And if so, wouldn't dumping them in the ocean stop them from detonating? The story should have ended with the captain rallying the loyal crew for a big fight, but the story is running out of pages, so the mutineers all flee to the life boats, but Cosmo punches out the ringleaders before they can board the boats (why the ring leaders wait so long, until all the other mutineers are at sea, before leaving the ship is not clear).
The Crimson Avenger returns! A rich man's daughter has been kidnapped, so the Crimson Avenger goes to work -- as reporter, Lee Travis. He apparently finds no useful clues, so he comes back that night as the Crimson Avenger and, at gunpoint, forces the dad to tell him where the drop point for the ransom money is. His only plan now is to follow the kidnappers' car from the drop point (are police not doing the same?).
The twist is that the kidnappers' hideout is a mansion in the suburbs. The Avenger even gives us the address for the mansion, 704 West Highway, "Scarchester." That sounds like Dorchester, Massachusetts to me. When he gets there, though, all the Avenger does is point a gun at the five kidnappers and wait for the police to arrive. Boring, and the art is terrible. What a bad comeback!
Sunday, January 17, 2021
Detective Comics #37 - pt. 1
One of the reasons I find the infallible Batman of today's comics so laughable is that he bears nothing but name and costume in common with this Batman, the Batman who gets lost and stops at a random house to ask for directions.
In the house, a man is being tortured by three mobsters. Despite the fact that one of them gets the drop on the Batman with a pistol, the Batman is still able to go first and kicks him in the face hard enough to knock him into the mobster behind him. Two game mechanic things here: one is that there is no order of battle in Hideouts & Hoodlums, where missiles always go before melee. The Batman has won initiative, so the advantage of already pointing a gun at him disappears. The other point is the two attacks. This should only be possible if the Batman has levels in fighter and these mobsters have less than 1 Hit Die, or if he was a superhero using the Multi-Attack power. Neither should be the case here, since the Batman is obviously a mysteryman. There is one more area with some wiggle room, and if you recall the Batman's stats from Supplement IV you know I already used it; the Batman's signature move is hitting mobsters with other mobsters. This is actually borne out in the following panels; the Batman drops those first two with one kick, but it takes him two punches to drop the third one, possibly because that mobster had more hit points, but also possibly because the Batman no longer has as good an attack bonus against a single opponent.
The first plot twist is that the tortured man, once freed, delivers a head blow that stuns the Batman (head blows are common enough that it is now a combat rule in 2nd edition). Because the Batman had already tied up the three mobsters, they are easy targets for the fourth man, Joey, when he uses a gun on them. If the tied-up men were Heroes, he would only get a +4 bonus to hit them (or at least the one who was only stunned and is awake already), but because these are just mobsters the Editor can handwave that and say they are each killed in one shot (as happens here).
The Batman's only clue as to where Joey went is that they all said they worked for a man named Turg. Later, Bruce Wayne remarks how uncommon that name is. No kidding, Bruce! Ancestry.com only lists six Turg families in Ontario, and none in the United States. But in this story, Bruce finds three in the New York City phone book and after visiting all three deduces the suspicious one is the one, Elias Turg, who opened a grocery store in a part of town without many houses in it. Most people would consider that a zoning issue, but to the Batman, it's a vital clue that turns out to be correct!
Later that night, the Batman barges into the upstairs office of the grocery store and finds Turg there with Joey and two more mobsters. He decides to intimidate them from the doorway first, spoiling any chance of a surprise attack. They are all 15-20' away, so the Batman can reach them easily for melee if he wants to, but this Batman doesn't feel infallible against four-to-one odds, so he turns off the lights and uses night-vision goggles. They aren't called night-vision goggles; the narrator calls it a "queer piece of glass," probably because the term "night-vision goggles" isn't in use yet. Night-vision devices are brand new on the battlefields of Europe, so new that I'm not sure the author (Comics.org credits Bill Finger) would even have heard of it yet and may have invented this idea independently.
After roughing them all up, the Batman does something I think is really clever; he pretends to leave and then hides before the lights come back on, so the mobsters will start to talk incriminatingly in front of him. It turns out, they aren't hoodlums but spies (or at least all of them but poor Joey, who they turn on and kill because the Batman called him out by name).
En route to the piers to commit sabotage, Elias Turg splits off from the other spies and the Batman has to choose who to follow. He follows the other spies to the pier, where they are met by two more spies. Actually three more spies, because Carl (probably the lookout) is on the balcony of a building behind the Batman and gains a surprise attack (because he is standing separate from the others, he gets his own separate surprise roll). He drops a heavy sack full of ...something heavy on the Batman's head and it counts as a head blow attack, stunning the Batman again. Instead of just shooting him and killing him (which actually makes sense here, since they don't want to alert the ship they plan to attack), the spies put him in a sack and toss him in the water. Stunning has a very short duration and the Batman is able to cut his way out of the sack with a knife in his utility belt before drowning.
When the Batman sneaks back up onto the pier, he switches to another favorite tactic of his, swinging on a rope to attack. It's very cinematic, but definitely would not improve his chance to hit. I think I talked about this before when he killed Jabbah this way and decided I might allow a +1 to damage for doing this, due to the additional momentum.
Despite beating all five spies in melee combat, they still managed to start the moto launch rigged with TNT that will blow up the docked steamer that was their target. The Batman tells his feet to run like they've "never run before," perhaps burning his first stunt of the night to run faster so he can reach the end of the pier in time to jump on board. Once he's on board, the cutting of the ropes holding the steering wheel and turning the wheel in time takes four panels, but there are no game mechanics in play anymore to resolve this, only stated intentions.
The story could have been over at this point, but there are two additional pages that seem rushed, as if tacked on. Joey had given the Batman the phone number for The Head (as in, the head of the operation) before dying, so the Batman finds out who's number that is and goes to his house. It's someone named Count Grutt and the Batman is either genuinely surprised or being sarcastic when he seems astonished that someone named Count Grutt is a foreign agent. Grutt is actually Turg without a disguise on (notice how the name is reversed; semi-clever, but if Grutt had gone by the name Smith, the Batman never would have found him).
Grutt/Turg has super-strength, able to throw a sword across a room with enough force that it goes halfway through a door. Count Grutt must be a supervillain, buffed with ...Extend Missile Range? Then the Batman pummels Grutt until he's down to zero hit points. With his last punch, the Batman must have pulled his punch a little and transferred some points of damage into pushing Grutt back, because Grutt falls back into the sword, which kills him, since he just took more damage while at zero hp. The Batman doesn't seem concerned.
(Read in Batman Archives vol. 1.)

















































